Skip to main content
LetCompliance
Letting Agents

How independent letting agencies win more landlord instructions

Landlords choose an agent on a few questions: what it costs and what is included, whether it lets homes like theirs, and how they will see their money. How an independent agency answers each, where its next instructions come from, and the follow-up that turns a valuation into a signature.

10 min read

Sample account, an agency’s letting pipeline: 6 properties to market and none yet at viewings, applications, holding deposit, agreement or ready to move in; 14 Brackenholt Road, Sheffield for Margaret Holroyd in the Sheffield branch, 19 Quarnby Rise, Leeds for Gail Whitworth and 27 Fennick Grove, Leeds for Priya Ashworth in the Leeds branch, each not advertised yet
Sample account, an agency’s landlord client: Margaret Holroyd, active, 2 properties, full management at 10% of rent
Sample account with made-up details, 18 Oct 2026

See how LetCompliance works for letting agents

A managed home is worth far more to an independent agency than its first month suggests. At an example fee of 12% on a £1,100 rent, one home brings in £1,584 a year in management fees; kept for five years, £7,920, before a single letting fee. Ten new instructions a year, kept, are what an agency is built on.

These are worked examples, not typical fees: put your own figures in.

Landlords choosing an agent ask the same few questions, and the agency that answers them before they are asked usually gets the instruction. This guide takes them in the order a landlord asks them, then sets out where instructions come from and the follow-up that turns a valuation into a signature. The legal set-up of a new agency is in how to start a letting agency, and taking a landlord on once they say yes is in onboarding a new landlord client.

What one instruction is worth

Rent a monthExample feeA year of management feesFive years
£90012%£1,296£6,480
£1,10012%£1,584£7,920
£1,50012%£2,160£10,800

Two things follow from the table. It is worth knowing what winning an instruction costs you: the hours on a valuation, the portal spend, the thank-you for a referral. And keeping a landlord is worth as much as winning a new one, which is the subject of why landlords leave their letting agent.

The first question: what will it cost, and what is included?

Almost every landlord asks the fee first and what it covers second. Answer both on one page before they ask.

The law already asks for part of this. A letting agent must publish its fees, each one with any VAT included, together with the redress scheme it belongs to and whether it is a member of a client money protection scheme, on its website and in each office (Consumer Rights Act 2015, s.83). Published fees are what landlords compare, often side by side, as on what letting agents charge.

A fee page that wins instructions goes further than that minimum:

  • Every fee as the landlord will pay it, VAT included
  • What each service covers, in a table, so a landlord can see what full management adds to rent collection, and rent collection to let-only
  • What costs extra, priced: a check-in, an extra inspection, a court attendance
  • A worked month: on a £1,100 rent, what the landlord receives after fees

A landlord who can work out their own figure before the valuation arrives ready to talk about the service rather than the price. Whether to lead with full management or let-only is weighed up in full management or let-only.

Proof that you let homes like theirs

A landlord with a terraced house wants to know you have let terraced houses near them, quickly, to tenants who paid. General claims do not show that. Local, specific, dated proof does.

  • Recent lets near them: the street (never the house number or the tenant), the rent achieved and how long it took
  • Your own figures, with the period stated: homes under management, rent paid on time, days to finish a repair, inspections carried out
  • Reviews from landlords, not only tenants, asked for when a landlord is pleased: after the first statement, or a re-let that took a week
  • A named person: who will look after their home, and how to reach them

Keep every figure a past result, worked out from your records, with the period beside it. A claim you cannot show the working for is one a landlord’s accountant will ask about.

The valuation that becomes an instruction

The valuation visit is the sale. Landlords tend to remember three things from it.

  1. 1A rent figure with its evidence. Comparable lets, how long they took, and what would put this home at the top of the range. Since 1 May 2026 the advert states the rent and offers above it cannot be accepted, so an honest figure counts for more than a hopeful one; the rent bidding guide covers pricing for it.
  2. 2What needs doing before it lets. An expired gas record, no electrical report, an EPC below E, a missing alarm. A landlord told at the valuation trusts you more than one told on move-in day.
  3. 3What happens next, in writing, within a day. The rent figure, the fee for the service they want, the date the home could be on the market, and the terms to sign.

Then follow up. Many valuations end with the landlord still deciding, and a well-timed follow-up is what moves the decision along.

Reporting is what you are selling

To a landlord the service is mostly invisible: they see the money and the messages. So show them what they will see before they sign.

  • A sample monthly statement, with the fees and a cost line, so they know it can be checked; what a landlord statement should include covers it
  • How repairs are approved: the limit they set, and the photos and quote they would get above it
  • The page they would have about their homes: this month’s rent, the certificate dates, open repairs and their statements

For a landlord who has changed agent before, the question behind the questions is often whether they will know what is going on. Showing the reporting answers it. What to send, and how often, is in what landlords expect from agent reporting.

Where the next instructions come from

Landlords you already look after

The cheapest instruction is the next home of a landlord you already have. Ask at each yearly review whether they are buying, and whether they know anyone who is letting. A landlord who is pleased with their statements tends to know other landlords.

Portfolio landlords

Landlords with several homes want figures they can use: one statement with a line for each home, a year’s figures on the tax year for their accountant, and a fee that reflects the number of homes. Put a portfolio rate in writing, and show them the yearly statement at the valuation.

Accidental landlords

Someone letting a home they used to live in, inherited or could not sell needs explanation more than a discount: what the law asks of them, what you will do, and what stays with them. A plain page on your website answering their first questions brings them to you. The accidental landlord guide covers what they face.

Landlords who manage their own homes

Self-managing landlords are a market too. Some want rent collection only, some want a tenant found and nothing more. A service they can step up from without starting again keeps them with you as the work grows.

People landlords already trust

Mortgage brokers, conveyancers, accountants and local estate agents all meet landlords at the moment they need an agent. An introduction works when each side knows what the other does well. Agree any payment for a referral in writing, and tell the landlord about it.

A follow-up routine for every valuation

  • The same day: a thank-you email with the rent figure and its evidence
  • The next day: the fees for the service they want, and the terms ready to sign
  • Day 3: a call to answer questions
  • Day 10: something new, such as a let nearby or an answer to something they asked
  • Day 30: a short note, and the prospect kept on your list
  • For every prospect: what they own, when it is free and what they asked, written down

Keep prospects in the same place as clients, so becoming a client is a change of status, not a copy and paste. A prospect who says no today may own a second home next year.

Pitching with your own figures

Past results from your own records, and a service the landlord can see before they sign. In a LetCompliance agency workspace, a landlord can be added as a prospect and becomes a client with a change of status. Performance shows, for the last 3, 6 or 12 months, occupancy of the recorded days, the median days to finish a repair, the share of rent paid by its due date and the inspections carried out. Its Summary for new landlords is a one-page PDF of the agency’s totals, with your logo where you have added one and no landlord names or addresses, made for pitching once you have at least 3 homes under management. Terms of business are prepared from the client record and signed online. Once a landlord signs, they can have a private, read-only page about their homes (a link, not a login) and their monthly statements emailed with the PDF. Agency plans start at £24 a month. Every agency plan has every agency tool and unlimited seats and branches; only the number of properties and the storage differ.

Frequently asked questions

How do letting agents get more landlords?

By answering a landlord’s questions before they are asked: a clear fee page with what each service includes, local proof of homes let, a valuation with an evidenced rent figure, a sample of the reporting they will get, and a follow-up after every valuation. The next home of an existing landlord is the cheapest instruction of all.

What do landlords look for when choosing a letting agent?

What it costs and what is included, proof that the agency lets homes like theirs, who will look after the home, and how they will see their money: statements, repairs and certificate dates.

Do letting agents have to publish their fees?

Yes. A letting agent in England must publish its fees, each with any VAT included, with the redress scheme it belongs to and whether it is in a client money protection scheme, on its website and in each office (Consumer Rights Act 2015, s.83).

What should a letting agent do after a valuation?

Send the rent figure and its evidence the same day, the fees and terms the next day, then call at around day 3 and follow up with something new at around day 10. Keep the prospect on file: a landlord who says no today may have another home to let next year.

Can a letting agency use its own results to win landlords?

Yes, as past results with the period stated and worked out from its records: occupancy, rent paid on time, repair times and inspections. Keep them to totals with no landlord, tenant or address that could be recognised.

Sources and scope

Every source above is a government or regulator’s page the guide cites, linked where it is used. This is guidance, not individual legal advice.

Ask an AI about this guide

Opens your assistant with this page as its source.

Share this guide

𝕏

You have read the guide. Now run the book.

Let and manage every landlord’s property from one workspace: adverts and referencing, the signed tenancy, rent and arrears, repairs and inspections, then each landlord’s statement and the client money report from the same records. Certificates, deposits and deadlines are tracked alongside.

Agency plans start at £24 a month, with unlimited branches and seats on every plan, a 14-day agency trial and no card.