Skip to main content
LetCompliance
Running Your Let

Can a tenant withhold rent for repairs? What the law allows in England, and the landlord’s best move (2026)

A tenant has no general right to stop paying rent until a repair is done. There is a narrow route to put repair costs against the rent, and a court can set disrepair damages against arrears, which is why the fastest repair is also the landlord’s cheapest one.

10 min read

Sample account, the Rent page, whoever owes most first: Ellie Northcott, 18 Harrowden Terrace, Sheffield, Room 1, £525 a month, overdue since 20 Oct 2026, £525 and 1 month’s rent owed; Lewis Grantham, Room 4, £495 a month, overdue since 24 Sept 2026, £495 and 1 month’s rent owed, Ground 8 from about 25 Nov 2026; Hannah Okafor, Room 3, £120 a week, overdue since 19 Oct 2026, £120 and 1 week’s rent owed; each with Mark paid, Part payment, Chase and Statement; then Aisha Rahman, Room 5, £575 a month, due today, up to date
Sample account, the room board on a phone: Room 4, Lewis Grantham, £495 a month, £495 behind
Sample account with made-up details, 18 and 21 Oct 2026

See how LetCompliance tracks rent arrears

No. A tenant in England has no general right to stop paying rent because a repair has not been done. Rent and repairs are separate promises in the same tenancy, and a tenant who simply stops paying is in arrears.

That is not the whole answer, though. The courts have long accepted a narrow route: money a tenant spends doing a repair that was the landlord's job can, in the right circumstances, count against the rent. And when a landlord sues for arrears, a tenant can set the damages for disrepair against what they owe. Both can cost the landlord far more than the repair would have.

You may have seen this week's headlines that tenants want a legal right to deduct repair costs from their rent. That is a proposal, not the law, and nothing below depends on it. This guide covers assured tenancies in England. The Act was read on legislation.gov.uk and the judgment on the National Archives' Find Case Law on 16 November 2026. It is not legal advice.

The landlord's repairing duty

Section 11 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 writes a repairing promise into most residential tenancies. The landlord must:

  • keep in repair the structure and exterior, "including drains, gutters and external pipes" (section 11(1)(a))
  • keep in repair and proper working order the installations for water, gas, electricity and sanitation, such as basins, sinks, baths and toilets (section 11(1)(b))
  • keep in repair and proper working order the installations for space heating and heating water (section 11(1)(c))

It does not cover what the tenant should do by using the home "in a tenant-like manner" (section 11(2)(a)): unblocking a sink they blocked, changing a fuse, keeping the place reasonably aired. And it gives the landlord a right in return: to enter at reasonable times, on 24 hours' notice in writing, to look at the condition of the home (section 11(6)).

A landlord can only fix what they know about, which is why a repair report that is dated and written down matters to both sides. The section 11 guide sets out the duty in full, and who pays for repairs covers the line between landlord and tenant.

What a tenant may lawfully do today

The Court of Appeal summed up the law in Smith v Muscat in 2003. Money a tenant spends on carrying out the landlord's repairing obligations "will in appropriate circumstances operate as a partial or a complete discharge so as to furnish a defence at law to a claim for unpaid rent". Where the tenant has not spent money but has suffered from the disrepair, "an equitable set-off is in appropriate circumstances available", and the court accepted that damages for breach of a repairing covenant and rent under the same agreement are close enough for that.

In plain terms there are two routes, and both are narrower than they sound:

  • Repair and deduct. The tenant pays for a repair that was the landlord's duty and counts the cost against the rent. It works only where the repair really was the landlord's job and the money was properly spent on it. "In appropriate circumstances" is doing a lot of work: a tenant who gets it wrong has simply paid less rent than was due
  • Set-off in a claim. The tenant does not deduct anything, but when the landlord sues for arrears, the tenant's claim for disrepair damages is set against the arrears. A court decides how much, if anything, the disrepair was worth

GOV.UK's guide for landlords says the same in one line. If you refuse to carry out repairs, your tenant can start a small claims court claim for repairs under £5,000, or "in some circumstances, carry out the repairs themselves and deduct the cost from their rent". And where a repair is a hazard, the tenant can ask the council to inspect the home under the Housing Health and Safety Rating System, and the council must act on a serious hazard it finds.

Neither route lets a tenant hold back the whole rent as leverage until the work is done. Withholding rent in protest is not spending money on the repair, and it is not a claim a court has valued yet.

The risk to a tenant who stops paying

A tenant who stops paying rent runs up arrears, and arrears are grounds for possession under Schedule 2 to the Housing Act 1988:

GroundWhat it needsMandatory or discretionary
Ground 8At least three months' rent unpaid on monthly rent (13 weeks' on weekly or fortnightly), both when the notice is served and at the hearingMandatory
Ground 10Some rent unpaid when the claim is issued, and in arrears when the notice was servedDiscretionary
Ground 11The tenant has persistently delayed paying rentDiscretionary

All three need four weeks' notice. The arrears grounds compared sets out each one.

Worked example. The rent is £950 a month. The boiler fails in November, the landlord is slow, and the tenant stops paying in protest. After three months the arrears are £2,850, which is exactly the Ground 8 line, and the landlord serves notice. Once the boiler is fixed the tenant pays again, so the arrears at the hearing are still £2,850.

At the hearing the tenant counterclaims for the months without heating, and the court values the disrepair at £600. Set against the arrears, that leaves £2,250, under the £2,850 line, so Ground 8 is no longer made out. Grounds 10 and 11 are left, and the judge decides whether possession is reasonable, knowing the landlord left a tenant without heating. The disrepair counterclaim guide works through that defence.

Compare the tenant who instead paid a heating engineer £380 for a repair that was clearly the landlord's, after telling the landlord in writing, and paid £570 that month. Whether that £380 counts against the rent is for a court if it comes to it, but it is a far stronger position than £2,850 withheld.

The landlord's best move: fix it fast and write it down

Every route above starts with a repair the landlord did not do. Fix it, and the tenant has nothing to deduct and nothing to set off.

  1. 1Log the report the day it comes in. Date, time, what the tenant said, photographs, how it arrived. A phone call counts: write it down
  2. 2Answer in writing. Say what you will do and when. If you need to see it, give 24 hours' written notice of the visit, at a reasonable time (section 11(6))
  3. 3Send the job. To your own contractor, with the address, the access arrangements, the photographs and what you want quoted or done
  4. 4Keep each step dated. When the contractor attended, what they found, what they did, the invoice, and when you told the tenant it was done
  5. 5Chase your own delays. A part on order is a reason; a contractor who has not been back for three weeks is not. Write down why each gap happened

Section 11 itself sets no deadline for a repair. How long a landlord has to fix a repair gives the usual working timescales. A dated record is what shows a judge, a council or a deposit scheme that you acted.

If the rent has stopped as well, deal with the two things separately: do the repair, and chase the arrears in writing. A landlord who fixed the boiler in four days and has the invoice to prove it is in a very different place from one who did not.

If the tenant has already deducted

If the rent arrives short with a note that it covers a repair:

  • Ask for the invoice. And the date the tenant first reported the problem
  • Check whose job it was. A section 11 repair you knew about and did not do is very different from a tenant replacing a kettle
  • Check the amount. Was it a fair price for the work, and was it the work that was needed?
  • Answer in writing. Accept it, or explain which part you dispute and why, and record the balance on the rent account either way

Do not treat a disputed deduction as a reason to serve notice straight away. If the repair was yours and the cost fair, the Court of Appeal's words above apply: in appropriate circumstances that money counts against the rent.

A dated record of every repair

Every repair, with its dates and photographs. In LetCompliance a tenant reports a repair through their portal with photographs, or you log one from a phone call, and each report carries a priority and a response clock as a guide. On the trial and paid plans you send the job to your own contractor from the same screen, approve their quote and keep the work history with its cost. The maintenance log keeps the cost and photographs against the property, and the written notice of a visit goes to the tenant from the inbox. The result is a record of when each step happened, for any question about who did what and when. Single, for one property, is £7.99 a month.

Frequently asked questions

Can a tenant legally withhold rent for repairs in England?

Not as a general right. A tenant who stops paying is in arrears. The courts accept a narrower route: money a tenant spends doing a repair that was the landlord’s duty can, in appropriate circumstances, count against the rent, and disrepair damages can be set against arrears in a claim (Smith v Muscat [2003] EWCA Civ 962).

Can a tenant deduct the cost of repairs from the rent?

Only in appropriate circumstances: the repair must have been the landlord’s duty and the money properly spent on it. A tenant who deducts for work that was not the landlord’s job, or more than the work was worth, has paid less rent than was due.

Is there a new law letting tenants deduct repair costs from rent?

No. In November 2026 there were calls for a legal right to deduct repair costs from rent. That is a proposal, not the law.

Can I evict a tenant who stops paying rent because of disrepair?

Arrears are grounds for possession (Grounds 8, 10 and 11), but a tenant can counterclaim for disrepair and the court sets the damages against the arrears. That can take the arrears below the Ground 8 line. See the disrepair counterclaim guide.

What repairs is a landlord responsible for?

Under section 11 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985: the structure and exterior, including drains, gutters and external pipes, and the installations for water, gas, electricity, sanitation, space heating and hot water. Not what the tenant should do by using the home in a tenant-like manner.

How should a landlord respond to a repair request?

Log it with the date and photographs, answer in writing with what you will do and when, give 24 hours’ written notice for any visit, send the job to a contractor and keep every step dated. A fast, recorded repair leaves nothing to deduct or set off.

Sources and scope

Every source above is a government or regulator’s page the guide cites, linked where it is used. This is guidance, not individual legal advice.

Ask an AI about this guide

Opens your assistant with this page as its source.

Share this guide

𝕏

You have read the guide. Now run the let.

Advertise and reference tenants, sign the agreement, collect the rent, log repairs and keep the tax figures ready all year. Certificates, deposits and deadlines are tracked alongside, so nothing expires unnoticed.

Plans from £7.99 a month, with a 3-day trial and no card. Making Tax Digital, recognised by HMRC, comes with every paid plan, not the trial.