When a group of friends or students asks to rent your house, there are two ways to let it. One joint tenancy for the whole house, with every sharer named on it and the rent due from them together. Or a tenancy for each room, with each sharer paying their own rent and sharing the kitchen and bathroom.
The higher total rent of a room let looks like the obvious winner. It often is not, once the bills, the empty weeks and the extra work are counted. This guide sets out what each way does to the money and the time, so you can choose for your house. The legal detail of each piece is in the guides linked as you go.
The two ways side by side
| One joint tenancy | A tenancy for each room | |
|---|---|---|
| The rent | One rent for the house | A rent for each room, usually more in total |
| Who owes it | Every tenant, for all of it | Each tenant, for their own room |
| The bills | Usually the tenants’ | Usually yours, included in the rent |
| When someone leaves | One notice can end the tenancy for everyone | That room is re-let; the others carry on |
| Empty months | The whole house at once | One room at a time |
| The deposit | One, for the tenancy | One for each room |
| Your time | Less: one tenancy to run | More: a changeover for each room |
Neither column decides whether the house is an HMO or needs a licence. That depends on who lives there, not on how the paperwork is written (see below).
A worked year on a four-bedroom house
An illustration, with figures invented to show the sum, not market rents. Replace them with your own.
| A year | One joint tenancy | Four rooms let separately |
|---|---|---|
| Rent | £1,800 a month for the house: £21,600 | £560 a month for each room: £26,880 |
| Bills you pay (energy, water, broadband) | None: the tenants pay them | £320 a month: £3,840 |
| Council tax, if the council bills you | None in this example | £180 a month: £2,160 |
| Empty time | 1 month with the house empty: £1,800 | Half a month for each room: £1,120 |
| Left after those costs | £19,800 | £19,760 |
In this illustration the two land within £40 of each other. The extra rent from the rooms goes on the bills, the council tax and the room-by-room empty weeks. Your own figures will differ, and that is the point of working them: the gap between a whole-house rent and four room rents is not profit until the costs the room let brings with it are taken off.
Two costs are missing from the table because they are yours to count. With rooms, each changeover means an advert, viewings, a reference, a new agreement and a check-in, perhaps four times a year rather than once every year or two. And bills included in the rent rise when prices rise, while the rent can be raised at most once a year, by a Section 13 notice. Bills included in the rent covers how to price them and what a fair usage clause can and cannot do, and setting room rents how to price each room.
Arrears: everyone owes it, or each owes their own
On a joint tenancy each tenant is liable for the whole rent, not just their share. If one sharer stops paying, you can ask any of the others for the shortfall, and the deposit covers the household. That is a real protection, but it puts you in the middle of a falling-out between friends, and the ones who paid rarely thank you for asking. More on how joint and several liability works in joint vs sole tenancies.
On room lets each tenant owes their own rent only. One sharer in arrears costs you a quarter of the house’s income, not all of it, but you chase that one tenant alone, with that one room’s deposit behind it.
For a group who already know each other and want to live together, the joint tenancy usually fits. For people who arrive separately, or a house where the faces change each year, rooms usually do.
When a sharer leaves
This is where the two differ most in practice.
On a joint tenancy, one tenant’s notice can end the tenancy for all of them, including the sharers who want to stay. You then sign a new tenancy with those who remain and anyone they bring in. If they find a replacement and ask you to swap the names instead, the Tenant Fees Act lets you charge for changing the tenancy at the tenant’s request, but anything above £50, or your reasonable costs if higher, is a prohibited payment (Schedule 1, paragraph 6). One joint tenant wants to leave covers the notice itself.
On room lets, the leaving tenant gives notice on their room, and only that room needs a new tenant. The house keeps earning while you fill it, which is why the empty weeks in the worked year are shorter for each room. The cost is that you find, reference and move in a stranger to a house of people who did not choose them, so a quick introduction at the viewing saves trouble later.
Students move as a group on the academic year, which suits a joint tenancy. Since the Renters’ Rights Act every assured tenancy is periodic, and Ground 4A is the route to regain a student house for the next year’s group: student lets and Ground 4A sets out when it applies. GOV.UK says households where everyone is a full-time student do not have to pay council tax.
Licensing does not follow the paperwork
A house is an HMO when it is let to people who do not form a single household and who share facilities (Housing Act 2004, section 254). GOV.UK puts it as a property rented out by at least 3 people who are not from 1 household, sharing facilities like the bathroom and kitchen. Four friends on one joint tenancy are four households, so the house is an HMO whether you let it as one tenancy or four.
A large HMO, rented to 5 or more people who form more than 1 household, needs a licence in England, and smaller ones may need one depending on the council’s area. Check with the council before you let, whichever way you choose. The HMO licence checker is a starting point, and the HMO management duties (the common parts, the fire safety, the information you display) apply either way.
Council tax can change with the way the house is let, and the rules differ between England and Wales: council tax on HMOs sets out who is billed. Ask the council how it will bill your house before you set a bills-included rent.
The deposit and the agreement
On a joint tenancy there is one deposit, protected once, with every tenant’s details and the Prescribed Information given to each of them and to anyone who paid on their behalf, within 30 days (Housing Act 2004, section 213). At the end it is returned as the agreement says, so name a lead tenant for the deposit in it, or say how the deposit is split between those who paid.
On room lets each room has its own deposit, protected and with its own Prescribed Information, and its own agreement naming the room, the shared areas the tenant can use, and what the rent includes. Whichever way you choose, every tenant should sign before they move in.
Choosing for your house
- 1Work the year both ways with your own rents, your bills and a fair guess at the empty weeks
- 2Ask who the sharers are: a settled group suits a joint tenancy; strangers and a changing cast suit rooms
- 3Count your time: four changeovers a year is a second job for some landlords and a normal month for others
- 4Check the licence with the council, because it applies either way
- 5Ask the council about council tax before you include bills in a room rent
One house, as one property or four rooms. In LetCompliance a house let room by room is one property, with each room’s own rent, tenant, arrears and bills-included flag, and each room’s floor area checked against the licence room sizes. Each empty room shows on the vacancies board at its own rent. A joint tenancy is one tenancy with every sharer named on the agreement, signed online, and when one of them leaves, End tenancy offers a new Direct Debit request to each tenant who stays. Plans run from £7.99 a month, and a house let as rooms counts as one property on your plan. See HMO management.