Skip to main content
LetCompliance
Deposit

Custodial vs Insured Deposit Protection: Who Holds the Money, and What It Costs

In a custodial scheme the scheme holds the deposit for free; in an insured scheme you keep the money and pay the scheme a fee to insure it. Both protect the tenant in law the same way. The difference is cash, cost and who pays the tenant back at the end.

8 min read

Sample account, Deposits: every tenancy’s deposit, where it is protected, whether the Prescribed Information was given within the 30 days and what happened to it when the tenancy ended. Held now £9,930 on 11 current tenancies, 0 not protected in time, 0 with the Prescribed Information not recorded and 0 awaiting return, with Export CSV
Sample account, Deposits on a phone: Flat 3, 27 Kingsley Road, Sheffield, Owen Fletcher since 1 November 2026, amount £980, scheme DPS
Sample account with made-up details, 18 Oct 2026

See how LetCompliance handles deposits

A custodial deposit scheme holds the tenant's deposit itself, in its own account, and charges you nothing. An insured scheme lets you (or your agent) keep the deposit, and you pay the scheme to insure it. That is the whole difference in one line: custodial is free and the money leaves your account; insured costs a fee and the money stays with you.

Either way you must protect the deposit within 30 days of receiving it and give the tenant the prescribed information. The Act allows both kinds, and the three schemes in England and Wales are the Deposit Protection Service, mydeposits and the Tenancy Deposit Scheme. The choice is about cash, cost and who handles the money when the tenancy ends.

What the law says each one is

The Housing Act 2004 defines both, in Schedule 10. The custodial one reads:

A "custodial scheme" is a scheme under which (a) tenancy deposits in connection with assured tenancies are paid to the landlords under the tenancies, (b) amounts representing the deposits are then paid by the landlords into a designated account held by the scheme administrator, and (c) those amounts are kept by the scheme administrator in that account until such time as, in accordance with the scheme, they fall to be paid (wholly or in part) to the landlords or tenants under the tenancies.

Under an insurance scheme, by contrast, the landlord keeps the deposit. At the end, the amount agreed with the tenant is repaid to them, and any amount the tenant asks for that is not repaid goes into the scheme's account when the scheme directs. Landlords undertake to reimburse the scheme, and the scheme keeps insurance against landlords who fail to follow its directions.

GOV.UK puts it more simply: in a custodial scheme "the scheme hold the deposit for free"; in an insured scheme "you or the agent holds the deposit and you pay the scheme to insure it".

Side by side

CustodialInsured
Who holds the money during the tenancyThe scheme, in its own accountYou or your agent
What it costs youNothingA fee to the scheme, set by each scheme
Interest on the moneyThe scheme may keep itNot set by the Act
End of tenancy, amount agreedThe scheme pays out within 10 days of being toldYou pay the tenant within 10 days of agreeing
End of tenancy, amount disputedThe money is already with the schemeYou pay the disputed amount to the scheme when it directs you, within 10 days
If the landlord cannot payNot an issue: the scheme has the moneyThe scheme's insurance repays the tenant, and the landlord must reimburse the scheme

Either way the deposit is protected in law, and under an insured scheme the scheme's insurance stands behind a landlord who fails to pay.

How custodial protection works, step by step

  1. 1Take the deposit, within the cap: five weeks' rent where the annual rent is under £50,000, six weeks' at or above it.
  2. 2Register the deposit with the scheme and pay the money into its account within 30 days of receiving it. Under a custodial scheme, paying the money in is the protection.
  3. 3Give the tenant the prescribed information within the same 30 days (what it must contain is in the prescribed information guide).
  4. 4At the end, agree the return with the tenant and tell the scheme. It pays the agreed amounts within 10 days of being notified.
  5. 5If you cannot agree, the money stays with the scheme until the dispute is settled, by agreement, the scheme's dispute service or a court. If one side stops responding, the Act lets the other apply to the scheme alone.

Because the scheme holds the cash, nothing depends on your bank balance at the end of the tenancy. For a landlord with a handful of lets, that is most of the case for custodial.

How insured protection works, step by step

  1. 1Take the deposit and keep it, within the same cap.
  2. 2Register it with the scheme within 30 days, on the scheme's terms, which include its fee.
  3. 3Give the prescribed information within the same 30 days.
  4. 4At the end, repay the tenant the amount you agree, within 10 days of agreeing.
  5. 5If the tenant asks for money you have not repaid after 10 days, the scheme directs you to pay the amount in question into its account, and you have 10 days to do it. It holds that money until the dispute is settled, then pays it out within 10 days.

The deposit sits in your account, but it is the tenant's money, held to be paid back. Spending it on a boiler in month three means finding it again at the end, on a 10-day clock. The case for insured is paying agreed returns directly and quickly, without waiting on a scheme, for a landlord or agent who holds enough deposits to make that worth the fee.

Which one should you choose?

Custodial, if you let a few properties yourself, you would rather the money were out of your account, or you want the scheme to handle the payout. It costs nothing, so it is never the more expensive option.

Insured, if you are comfortable holding tenants' money apart from your own, you want to pay agreed returns the day you agree them, and you manage enough tenancies that the fee buys you that control.

Is insured ever cheaper? No. Custodial protection is free; insured protection always carries a fee. The case for insured is control of the payout, not price. Which company to use is a separate choice, covered in TDS vs DPS vs mydeposits.

What happens if the deposit is not protected

Whichever kind you choose, protecting late or not at all has the same consequence. GOV.UK says a court can order you to repay the deposit or pay it into a custodial scheme's account within 14 days, and to pay the tenant up to three times the deposit. The deposit penalty calculator shows the range for your deposit, and the deposit protection guide covers what else it affects.

Keeping every deposit on its clock

Protected on time, returned on time. LetCompliance runs the let from one login, and its deposits register, on every plan including the free one, holds each tenancy's deposit: the amount, the scheme, whether it was protected inside its 30 days, the prescribed information as a PDF naming every landlord, and the return at the end, with email reminders 14, 7 and 1 days before the protection deadline. At check-out, on the trial and paid plans from £7.99 a month, the inventory comparison pairs the check-in and check-out reports and works out the claim for each damaged item from its replacement cost and remaining life, leaving fair wear and tear out; on paid plans the deposit dispute pack puts the evidence into one PDF for TDS, DPS or mydeposits. See deposit deductions.

Frequently asked questions

What does a custodial deposit scheme mean?

The scheme holds the tenant’s deposit in its own account for the whole tenancy, free of charge to you. At the end it pays out the amounts you and the tenant agree, within 10 days of being told, and keeps any disputed money until the dispute is settled.

What is the difference between custodial and insured deposit protection?

Who holds the money. In a custodial scheme the scheme holds it, free. In an insured scheme you or your agent keep it and pay the scheme a fee to insure it, and you repay the tenant yourself at the end. Both protect the tenant to the same legal standard.

Is insured deposit protection cheaper than custodial?

No. Custodial protection costs nothing; insured protection carries a fee set by each scheme. Landlords choose insured for control of the payout and the cash, not to save money.

How long do I have to protect a deposit?

30 days from receiving it, under either kind of scheme, with the prescribed information given to the tenant in the same 30 days. The deposit protection deadline calculator gives the last day.

What happens to an insured deposit in a dispute?

If the tenant asks for money you have not repaid within 10 days, the scheme directs you to pay the amount in question into its account, and you must do so within 10 days. It holds the money until the dispute is settled, then pays it out within 10 days.

Sources and scope

All 7 sources

Every source above is a government or regulator’s page the guide cites, linked where it is used. This is guidance, not individual legal advice.

Ask an AI about this guide

Opens your assistant with this page as its source.

Share this guide

𝕏
Free PDF, instant by email

New Tenancy Document Checklist

What to give a new tenant in England, and when: before the tenancy is agreed, before they move in, and within 30 days of taking the deposit. With the source and the penalty for each.

  • Written statement of terms before the tenancy is agreed
  • Gas, electrical and EPC certificates before move-in
  • Deposit protection and prescribed information within 30 days
  • What not to give a new tenant any more

The guides only come if you tick the box, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

You have read the guide. Now run the let.

Advertise and reference tenants, sign the agreement, collect the rent, log repairs and keep the tax figures ready all year. Certificates, deposits and deadlines are tracked alongside, so nothing expires unnoticed.

Plans from £7.99 a month, with a 3-day trial and no card. Making Tax Digital, recognised by HMRC, comes with every paid plan, not the trial.