Skip to main content
LetCompliance

Landlord glossaryPossession

Disrepair Counterclaim

A claim a tenant makes back against the landlord within a possession or money claim, saying the landlord failed to carry out repairs and owes compensation. The tenant raises it on the defence form, and GOV.UK tells tenants a counterclaim carries a court fee. Where it succeeds, any compensation can be set against what the tenant owes, which can reduce the sum due or change whether a possession order is made.

Collect the rent, log every cost and keep the tax figures ready, from £7.99 a month.

Checked against GOV.UK and legislation.gov.ukLast reviewed 16 November 2026How facts are checked

Raised on
The defence form sent with the claim
Usual basis
Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, s.11 repairing duty
Effect
Compensation can be set against rent owed
Fee
Payable by the tenant on a counterclaim

Why it matters

What Disrepair Counterclaim means for a landlord

A counterclaim can turn a claim based on unpaid rent into a contest about the state of the home. Where a court finds the landlord in breach of the repairing duty, damages can wipe out part or all of what the tenant owes; on Ground 8 that can take the debt below the threshold at the hearing. The best defence is a record kept long before any claim: repair requests, dates, contractor visits and replies. Wales and Scotland have their own repair standards. Related: Disrepair, Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 (Section 11), Ground 8 (Serious Rent Arrears) and Damp and Mould.

Common mistakes

Where landlords go wrong

  1. 01Issuing a claim with open repair requests left unanswered.
  2. 02Having no dated record of when repairs were reported and done.
  3. 03Assuming a counterclaim cannot touch a mandatory ground.

What to do

A short checklist

  • Log every repair request and visit against the property as it happens.
  • Clear open repairs before serving notice where you can.
  • Build the hearing file with the evidence bundle guide.

LetCompliance’s Section 8 notice builder drafts Form 3A from your own records, with the earliest date for court worked out as you tick each ground. See plans and prices

Sources

Checked against these sources on 16 November 2026. A guide to the rules in England, not legal advice: for a dispute or a possession claim, speak to a solicitor.