With a second app
1. Sign in and enter a code from the other app.
2. Open Settings and the Security tab.
3. Press Remove beside the lost phone’s app and confirm with a code from the app you still have. The lost one can be removed even though its phone has gone.
With no second app
1. Email hello@letcompliance.com from the address you sign in with.
2. Say the phone was lost. The request is checked by hand, which protects you from someone pretending to be you.
3. Once two-step sign-in is taken off, sign in with your password and set up an authenticator app again on Settings, Security.
Avoiding the wait next time
There are no backup codes. Press Add a backup app on the Security tab and add a second app, on a tablet or in a password manager that shows codes. Either app then signs you in.