Your tenant pays on time, looks after the place and has been there three years. Similar homes nearby are advertised for more than they pay. Raise the rent and you might lose them; leave it and the gap costs you every month. Most landlords decide this on a feeling. It is a sum, and a short one.
This guide is the arithmetic: what an empty month really costs, how many months of a rise it takes to pay for one, and how the chance of losing the tenant and a tribunal challenge change the answer. The rules for raising the rent are in how much can a landlord increase rent, and the notice itself in the Section 13 notice.
What one empty month really costs
The lost rent is the cost everyone counts. A change of tenant brings others with it. On a home let at £1,000 a month, an illustration:
| Cost of a change of tenant | In this example |
|---|---|
| One month with no rent | £1,000 |
| Council tax and standing charges while it is empty | £180 |
| Cleaning, small repairs and re-letting costs | £320 |
| Total | £1,500 |
Your figures will differ: council tax on an empty home depends on your council, and the re-letting costs on what you do yourself. The void cost calculator works it out on your own rent and costs. Two empty months, which is common when a tenant leaves in winter, takes the example to about £2,700.
The point is the size of it. A change of tenant on a £1,000 rent costs about a month and a half of rent, before your own time on the check-out, the viewings and the new tenancy.
How many months of a rise pay for one empty month
Divide the cost of a change of tenant by the extra rent a month. That is how long the higher rent must be paid before you are back where you started.
| Increase on £1,000 | Extra a month | Extra a year | Months to cover £1,000 of lost rent | Months to cover the full £1,500 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3% | £30 | £360 | About 33 | 50 |
| 5% | £50 | £600 | 20 | 30 |
| 8% | £80 | £960 | About 13 | About 19 |
| 10% | £100 | £1,200 | 10 | 15 |
| 15% | £150 | £1,800 | About 7 | 10 |
Read the 5% row. If a 5% rise costs you the tenant and one empty month, the higher rent from the next tenant needs 20 months just to replace the lost rent, and 30 months to cover the whole change. Most rises do not cost the tenant, which is why the next step matters.
Weigh it by the chance they leave
You cannot know whether a tenant will leave over a rise, but you can put a rough figure on it from what you know of them: their income, how settled they are, whether similar homes nearby really are let for more. Multiply that chance by the cost of a change, and set the answer beside what the rise brings in.
A 5% rise on £1,000 brings in £600 in a year. Against a change costing £1,500:
| Chance the rise costs you the tenant | Expected cost of a change | The rise, less that cost, roughly |
|---|---|---|
| 1 in 10 | £150 | £450 ahead |
| 1 in 5 | £300 | £300 ahead |
| 2 in 5 | £600 | About even |
| 1 in 2 | £750 | £150 behind |
The rough rule from this example: a 5% rise pays in its first year if the chance it costs you the tenant is well under 2 in 5. A bigger rise brings in more, but it usually raises the chance too, and it is the one most likely to be challenged.
The tribunal factor
Since 1 May 2026 a rent increase on an assured periodic tenancy goes through a Section 13 notice on Form 4A, even when you and the tenant have already agreed it, with at least 2 months’ notice, and no sooner than 52 weeks after the tenancy began or the last increase took effect (GOV.UK; Housing Act 1988, section 13).
The tenant can ask the First-tier Tribunal to decide the rent before it is due to start. Two things then follow from the Act:
- The tenant never pays more than you proposed. The new rent is the open-market rent the tribunal decides if it is lower than your figure, and your figure otherwise (section 14ZB).
- The rise waits for the decision. Where the date in your notice has passed by the time the tribunal decides, the new rent starts from the first rent period on or after the decision, so the months in between are paid at the old rent.
How often the figure comes down. LetCompliance counted the tribunal’s market rent decisions published on GOV.UK. Of the 337 made since 1 May 2026 with readable figures, the tribunal set a lower rent than the landlord proposed in 69%, the same rent in 25% and a higher one in 6%. Where both figures could be read (334 decisions), the median increase proposed was 15.3% and the median set was 8.8%. The decisions include some housing association tenancies. The full count is in rent tribunal challenges.
For the sum, that means a large rise has two discounts on it: a higher chance the tenant leaves, and a real chance the figure is cut and starts later. A rise close to what similar homes are let for, with the evidence in hand, carries neither.
A worked decision
A flat let at £950 a month to a tenant of three years. Similar flats nearby are advertised at about £1,050. A change of tenant would cost about £1,450: one month at £950 and £500 of other costs. The chances below are the landlord’s own judgement, an illustration rather than data.
| Option | Extra a year if the tenant stays | Chance they leave over it | Expected cost of a change | Net in the first year, roughly |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Keep the rent at £950 | £0 | Very low | £0 | £0 |
| Raise to £1,000 | £600 | 1 in 10 | £145 | £455 ahead |
| Raise to £1,050 | £1,200 | 1 in 3 | £483 | £717 ahead, before a tribunal challenge |
The bigger rise looks better until the tribunal is counted. If the tenant applies and the tribunal sets £1,000, the gain halves to £600 and starts later, while the chance of a change stays at 1 in 3. The rise to £1,000, with the comparable adverts kept on file, is the steadier choice this year, and the rent can be reviewed again once 52 weeks have passed.
Run the same table on your own figures. When the answer is close, keeping a good tenant is usually worth more than the last £50.
Ways to lower the risk
- Talk first. GOV.UK says to discuss a rise with the tenant before the notice. A conversation about the figure and the reason heads off most referrals.
- Keep the evidence. Save dated copies of adverts for similar homes nearby: the same size, condition and street type. It is what you will need if the figure is challenged.
- Smaller and regular beats large and rare. A modest rise each year keeps the rent near the market, and avoids the large jump that tenants refer.
- Get the notice right. Form 4A, at least 2 months’ notice, a start date at the beginning of a rent period, and 52 weeks since the last increase. The step-by-step is in the Section 13 notice guide, and the dates in the Section 13 calculator.
- Look after the tenant. Repairs done promptly do more for a renewal than any letter: keeping good tenants.
Rent reviews in LetCompliance
Every rent, its last increase and the earliest new date, on one board. In LetCompliance the rent review board lists each current tenancy with its rent, the date of its last increase and the earliest date a new rent could start. Select the tenancies to review and Form 4A is prepared for each one in turn, with the earliest lawful start date worked out from the 2 months’ notice and the 52 weeks; each notice is still checked and sent on its own. If a tenant does leave, the advert, applications and viewings for the next let are in the same login, and the void cost calculator sets the empty weeks against the rise.
Section 13 notices and the rent review board come with every paid plan, from Single at £7.99 a month for one property. The steps are in preparing notices for several tenants.