Why it matters
What Discretionary Ground means for a landlord
On a discretionary ground, proving the facts is only half the case: the landlord also has to persuade the court that possession is reasonable, and the tenant’s circumstances, the landlord’s conduct and how serious the breach is all count. That is why landlords name a mandatory ground too where one genuinely applies. In Scotland every eviction ground for a private residential tenancy is discretionary, and the First-tier Tribunal looks at all the circumstances. Related: Mandatory Ground, Suspended Possession Order and Schedule 2 (Housing Act 1988 Possession Grounds).
Common mistakes
Where landlords go wrong
- 01Assuming possession follows automatically once the facts are proved.
- 02Bringing no evidence about why possession is reasonable.
- 03Not preparing for a suspended order on terms.
What to do
A short checklist
- List the facts that make possession reasonable, not just the ground.
- Keep correspondence that shows you acted fairly.
- See every ground in the notice period table.
LetCompliance’s Section 8 notice builder drafts Form 3A from your own records, with the earliest date for court worked out as you tick each ground. See plans and prices
Sources
- legislation.gov.uk: Housing Act 1988, Schedule 2
- legislation.gov.uk: Housing Act 1988, section 7
- legislation.gov.uk: Housing Act 1988, section 9
Checked against these sources on 16 November 2026. A guide to the rules in England, not legal advice: for a dispute or a possession claim, speak to a solicitor.