Skip to main content
LetComplianceLandlord & property management software

Section 13 Rent Tribunal Challenge 2026

Under the Renters’ Rights Act 2025 tenants can challenge any Section 13 rent increase at the First-tier Tribunal. Here’s how the process works, what evidence wins, and how to set a defensible rent from the start.

Rent Arrears17 min read
Sample account, Form 4A for Room 1, 18 Harrowden Terrace, Sheffield, Rent and dates: current rent £525.00, the tenancy’s rent now; notice date 18/10/2026; rent is paid monthly; the tenancy started on 20/09/2025; most recent increase and first increase after 11 Feb 2003 left blank
Sample account, the rent review board on the landlord’s phone: every current tenancy, the rent it pays, when it last went up and the earliest date a Section 13 increase could start. All 11, can serve now 7, not yet 4. First, 18 Harrowden Terrace, Sheffield, Room 1, Ellie Northcott, can serve now, £525 a month, earliest new rent 20 December 2026, serve by 20 October 2026
Sample account, Form 4A on a phone for Room 1: earliest date the new rent can start, 20 December 2026
Sample account with made-up details, 18 Oct 2026

See how LetCompliance does Section 13 increases

You want to put the rent up, and your tenant now has a simple way to push back. This guide shows you how to set a rent that holds up if they do, how the Tribunal process runs from start to finish, what evidence wins, and how to make a referral less likely in the first place.

The rules first. Under the Renters’ Rights Act 2025, the only way to raise the rent on an assured periodic tenancy in England is a formal rent increase notice (Section 13). You can use it not more often than every 52 weeks, with at least 2 months’ notice. Any rent-review clause that previously sat in your tenancy agreement is now unenforceable.

The tenant can challenge the increase at the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber, Residential Property). The tenant applies online or on form MR1, before the start date in your notice. The application usually costs £47. It is free where the notice is dated before 1 May 2026. Under the RRA’s new rule, the Tribunal may determine a higher or lower open-market rent, but the tenant can never be required to pay more than the landlord proposed. So you face one-way downside risk on every Section 13 notice you serve.

Disclaimer: this is editorial guidance. Complex or high-value rent-tribunal cases warrant a chartered surveyor’s valuation report and legal representation.


The rules in 2026

Section 13: the only rent-increase route

Under the Housing Act 1988 s.13, a landlord of an assured periodic tenancy in England must use Form 4A (the prescribed Section 13(2) notice) to propose a rent increase. Key requirements:

  • Minimum 2 months notice from service to effective date
  • At least 52 weeks between increases on the same tenancy, occasionally 53 under the Note A3 correction
  • Prescribed Form 4A (using outdated or non-prescribed forms voids the notice)
  • New rent must be stated, not a percentage or formula
  • Effective date must fall at the start of a rental period

What the Renters’ Rights Act 2025 changed

Three material changes:

  1. 1All periodic tenancies are Section 13 territory. Pre-RRA, some landlords used rent-review clauses in fixed-term ASTs to avoid Section 13. Fixed terms are now gone, so every rent rise is a Section 13.
  2. 2A referral cannot raise the rent above your proposal. The single biggest change for landlords. The tribunal decides the open-market rent, and the tenant pays that figure only if it is lower than the rent the landlord proposed; otherwise the proposed rent applies. This removes the old "bidding risk" that deterred frivolous tenant referrals.
  3. 3Deferred effective date if referred. The new rent starts on the date in your notice if the tribunal decides on or before that date. If it decides later, the new rent starts at the beginning of the first rent period on or after the decision, not backdated. Where that would cause the tenant undue hardship, the tribunal can direct a different date, no later than two months after its decision. The tenant remains on the old rent during the process.

What this means commercially

Because the tenant never pays more than the proposed rent, applying costs a tenant little beyond the application fee.

You can no longer set an optimistic headline rent and settle for the middle: you need to pitch the increase at a defensible market rent from the start.

From £7.99 a month, on paid plans, LetCompliance dates the Form 4A for you with the two-month and 52 or 53-week rules checked, and keeps the notice on the property record next to the rent history. Get started


How the tenant’s referral works

Tenant’s timeline to apply

The tenant must apply to the First-tier Tribunal before the new rent takes effect. They apply online or on form MR1.

The application usually costs £47. It is free where the notice is dated before 1 May 2026.

Acknowledgement and directions

The Tribunal then issues:

  • An acknowledgement confirming receipt
  • Directions setting deadlines for landlord and tenant to submit evidence bundles
  • A hearing date, or notice that the case will proceed on papers

Paper determination vs oral hearing

A case can be decided on papers (no oral hearing), and either party can ask for an oral hearing.

The Tribunal’s job

Under s.14 Housing Act 1988 (as amended), the Tribunal must determine the rent the property could reasonably command in the open market. That is the hypothetical rent a willing landlord and a willing tenant would agree for the same property in its current condition, disregarding any effect on rent of the tenant’s improvements.

The tribunal decides the open-market rent, and that figure can come out higher or lower than yours. What changed on 1 May 2026 is what the tenant pays: the open-market rent if it is lower than your proposal, and your proposed rent otherwise (Housing Act 1988 s.14ZB(5)). A notice served before 1 May 2026 is still decided under the old rules.

The decision

The Tribunal sends a written decision. The decision:

  • Sets the open-market rent; the tenant pays the lower of that and your proposal
  • Is binding and only appealable with permission on a point of law

The new rent starts on the date in your notice if the tribunal decides on or before that date. If it decides later, the new rent starts at the beginning of the first rent period on or after the decision, not backdated. Where that would cause the tenant undue hardship, the tribunal can direct a different date, no later than two months after its decision.


What evidence wins a Section 13 case

What the tribunal has set so far, against what landlords proposed, is in the tribunal decisions since May, counted.

1. Comparable evidence (the most important)

The Tribunal is a comparables-based body. Bring 3+ comparable current lettings of similar properties in the same area:

  • Rightmove / Zoopla screenshots dated within the last 30 days, showing asking rent, size, condition, terms
  • Agent confirmations (emailed) of actual let rents in the last 3–6 months. These carry more weight than asking rents
  • Photos of comparable exteriors where possible (to show property type/condition similarity)

Comparables should match on: bedrooms, property type (flat/house/terrace/semi/detached), location (same postcode or within 0.5 miles for urban, 1–2 miles for rural), condition (standard / above / below), letting terms (furnished / unfurnished, pet policy).

2. Condition evidence

Photos of the property interior (every room), exterior, and any specific features (garden, parking, appliances). Dated photos from the last 30 days are ideal.

3. Certification evidence

Bring your current:

  • EPC (Band E+ minimum, Band C adds market premium)
  • Gas Safety Certificate
  • EICR

Well-certificated properties justify higher market rents. A Band A–C EPC is a meaningful data point for the Tribunal.

4. Improvements since the last review

If you’ve done capital improvements since the last rent review (new kitchen, new bathroom, double glazing, solar, etc.), bring invoices and before/after photos. The Tribunal can factor these into the market-rent assessment.

5. Professional valuation (optional but powerful)

A lettings valuation from a RICS chartered surveyor or a senior ARLA Propertymark letting agent produces an independent market-rent opinion. This carries significant weight, especially in high-value or contested cases.

6. Your current-tenancy context

Bring the current tenancy agreement, rent history (a simple ledger showing rent paid each month), and any prior Section 13 notices. This demonstrates the "uplift story": where rent has been and what the gap is to current market.


What does NOT win a Section 13 case

  1. 1"My costs went up." The Tribunal’s job is to find market rent, not to cover your mortgage interest or insurance costs. Rising costs are irrelevant.
  2. 2"Inflation / RPI / CPI." Tribunal rent reviews are not indexation exercises. An inflation argument without comparable evidence will be rejected.
  3. 3"I need this rent to break even." Landlord commercial position is irrelevant. Tribunal sets open-market rent regardless of your yield.
  4. 4"The tenant’s circumstances have changed." The Tribunal does not assess whether the tenant can afford the increase, only the market rent.
  5. 5Generic Rightmove searches without filtering. A screenshot of Rightmove showing "average rent in SW17 = £2,200" without comparable specificity is weak evidence. You need like-for-like comparables.

The 7-step landlord playbook

Step 1: Set a defensible rent before you serve

Before drafting Form 4A, collect 5–7 comparable current lettings for your property. Pitch your new rent at around the median of those comparables, perhaps 5% below the top, to leave a buffer for the Tribunal’s discretion. Think of this as pricing to avoid challenge rather than maximising nominal uplift.

Step 2: Use the current Form 4A

Download Form 4A ("Landlord’s notice proposing a new rent for an assured periodic tenancy") from the current GOV.UK page. An outdated copy, or Form 4 (the social housing version), voids the notice.

Step 3: Serve the notice properly

  • 2 months minimum notice
  • Effective date must align with the start of a rental period
  • Serve by a method that gives you proof of service (signed-for post, hand-delivery with witness, process server)

Step 4: Document everything

Save: Form 4A copy, proof of service, the comparables you relied on to set the rent (so if challenged, your evidence is ready). LetCompliance’s Section 13 builder keeps the notice and its dates on record; save your comparables alongside it.

Step 5: Watch for the tenant application

The tenant must refer the notice before the new rent takes effect, so watch for a referral until then. Tribunal letters can arrive by post or at your nominated email, so check both.

Step 6: Respond to Tribunal directions

When directions arrive, follow deadlines precisely. Prepare your evidence bundle including: updated comparables pack, condition photos, certificates, improvement invoices, optional professional valuation.

Step 7: Implement the outcome

  • If no referral: rent increases as per Form 4A.
  • If the Tribunal confirms your rent or reduces it: the new rent starts on the date in your notice if the tribunal decides on or before that date. If it decides later, the new rent starts at the beginning of the first rent period on or after the decision, not backdated. Where that would cause the tenant undue hardship, the tribunal can direct a different date, no later than two months after its decision. You cannot claim a backdated top-up for the processing period.

Minimising future referrals

Rent-review economics under RRA

You can’t increase the rent more often than every 52 weeks, and the Tribunal will never require the tenant to pay more than you asked for. It determines the market rent, which may come out higher or lower than your figure, but your own proposal caps what the tenant pays. So the traditional "annual 5% uplift" habit no longer serves you well. A better 2026 approach:

  • Pitch at median market rent with a 3–5% safety margin below top comparables
  • Serve 10–11 months after last review (not rushing to annual anniversary if rent is already at market)
  • Skip reviews where market rent has barely moved and tenant is otherwise excellent
  • Price new tenancies at market rent from the start, so later Section 13 rises stay modest

Track market rent quarterly

Don’t rely on a single comparables check at rent-review time. Track asking rents in your area every quarter using Rightmove/Zoopla filters. You’ll spot market shifts in time to calibrate your next notice.

Communicate with the tenant before you serve

A phone call or letter 3–4 weeks before Form 4A explaining the proposed increase and your reasons reduces the chance of a reflexive Tribunal application. Cooperative tenants who understand the market context are less likely to challenge.

Keep improvements documented

Every time you upgrade the property, log the work with invoice and photos in your document vault. At next rent review, you’ll have ready evidence to justify an uplift.


FAQs

How likely is a Section 13 challenge in 2026?

LetCompliance has counted the decisions made since 1 May 2026: what the tribunal decided. The incentives push challenges up, because the Tribunal may determine a higher or lower open-market rent, but the tenant can never be required to pay more than you proposed. Landlords who pitch well above market are the most exposed. Price to open-market evidence and keep comparables on file.

Can I withdraw a Section 13 notice to avoid the Tribunal?

The Act does not set out a way to withdraw a Section 13 notice, so take advice before you try. If the tenant has already applied to the Tribunal, you’ll need to co-operate with any directions.

Does a Tribunal rent decision bind future years?

No. The decision sets rent for this notice only. Another Section 13 notice can propose a new rent starting 52 weeks after this one took effect. The Tribunal’s earlier figure may be cited by the tenant in a second application, but it’s not formally binding on a fresh review.

Can I recover lost rent from the delay during the Tribunal process?

No. The new rent starts on the date in your notice if the tribunal decides on or before that date. If it decides later, the new rent starts at the beginning of the first rent period on or after the decision, not backdated. Where that would cause the tenant undue hardship, the tribunal can direct a different date, no later than two months after its decision. You cannot reclaim the period between your intended start date and the new rent starting.

What if the tenant doesn’t pay the new rent after the decision?

Rent arrears arising from the new rent can support a Section 8 Ground 8 possession claim once arrears reach the statutory threshold. See the how to evict a tenant UK 2026 guide.


Get started, from £7.99 a month. A rent review is part of running the let, so LetCompliance keeps it with the rest of the tenancy. On a paid plan the Section 13 builder fills in Form 4A with the dates worked out and keeps the notice on the property record. The rent ledger holds the rent history a Tribunal asks for, and your certificates, photos and invoices sit in the property’s documents. The comparables are yours to gather: the builder doesn’t include them.

Sources and scope

Every source listed above is on GOV.UK, legislation.gov.uk or HSE and reviewed against the live source every quarter. This is guidance, not individual legal advice.

Free PDF, instant by email

After Section 21: Possession Routes Map

Section 21 was abolished for private tenancies on 1 May 2026, and an older notice could be used only if the court was asked to issue a claim on it by 31 July 2026 at the latest. This map takes the reasons landlords served Section 21 and shows the Section 8 ground that fits.

  • Your reason for possession matched to a Section 8 ground
  • Notice period and the evidence the court will look for
  • What bars a possession order, and what no longer does
  • The first-year rule and the 12-month re-letting ban for Grounds 1 and 1A

The guides only come if you tick the box, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

Frequently asked questions

What is a First-tier Tribunal rent challenge under Section 13?

Under the Housing Act 1988 s.13 (as amended by the Renters’ Rights Act 2025), a tenant who receives a Section 13 rent increase notice can apply to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) within the notice period (before the increase takes effect). The Tribunal decides the market rent the property could achieve on an open-market letting with a willing landlord and willing tenant. If the Tribunal sets a lower rent, that becomes the rent. If it finds a higher one, the tenant still pays no more than you proposed (a change made by the Renters’ Rights Act 2025).

Can the Tribunal set the rent HIGHER than my Section 13 proposal?

The tribunal decides the open-market rent, and that figure can come out higher or lower than yours. What changed on 1 May 2026 is what the tenant pays: the open-market rent if it is lower than your proposal, and your proposed rent otherwise (Housing Act 1988 s.14ZB(5)). A notice served before 1 May 2026 is still decided under the old rules.

What evidence wins a Section 13 Tribunal case?

Three kinds of evidence matter most. (1) Comparable evidence: current market lettings of similar properties in the same area (dated Rightmove/Zoopla screenshots, agent confirmations, ideally 3+ comparables). (2) Condition evidence: photos and certificates showing the property’s current state. (3) Improvements evidence: invoices for works done since the last rent review. A professional lettings valuation from an ARLA Propertymark agent carries strong weight.

How long does a Section 13 Tribunal case take?

Timings vary, so there is no reliable typical figure. The Tribunal acknowledges the application, sets directions for both sides’ evidence, then decides on the papers or at a hearing and sends a written decision. The tenant applies online or on form MR1, before the start date in your notice. The application usually costs £47. It is free where the notice is dated before 1 May 2026.

Ask an AI about this guide

Opens your assistant with this page as its source.

Share this guide

𝕏

See how it works

Prefer to watch?

You have read the rule. Now run the let.

Advertise and reference tenants, sign the agreement, collect the rent, log repairs and keep the tax figures ready all year. Certificates, deposits and deadlines are tracked alongside, so nothing expires unnoticed.

Landlord software for the whole let

Plans from £7.99 a month, with a 3-day trial and no card. Making Tax Digital, recognised by HMRC, comes with every paid plan, not the trial.